Hmm. There's an entire debate about what is Science. Once upon a time it was an actual war. Known as "The Science Wars." With a history that the Marxists have been more keen on understanding than most other demo. Because Marx and Engels broached the subject. This is how they discussed Science:
"We know only a single science, the science of history. One can look at history from two sides and divide it into the history of nature and the history of men. The two sides are, however, inseparable; the history of nature and the history of men are dependent on each other so long as men exist. The history of nature, called natural science, does not concern us here; but we will have to examine the history of men, since almost the whole ideology amounts either to a distorted conception of this history or to a complete abstraction from it. Ideology is itself only one of the aspects of this history."
This is a distinction in Sciences that has been blurred. Because there are types, two general categories, Hard, Natural Science (Chemistry, Biology, Physics, etc) and Soft, Social Science (History, Sociology, Psychology, etc). When most people hear the term "Science" images of machines, microscopes, gyroscopes, chemical assays, etc come to mind. Which is useful for those employing Soft, Social Science to be associated with.
There's a reason the Soft, Social Sciences are also known as "Psuedoscience": Because they take on the appearance and many of the methodologies of Hard, Natural Science. But omit the critical validation steps of RCT, replicable, isolation for causality. For Soft, Social Science, observed correlation is sufficient, replication as a non-exact predictor. Hard, Natural Science demands exact predictability. 100% same result. Soft, Social Science accepts 70-80-90% same result. Results will vary, but a statistically significant percentage of them will be the same.
Social Sciences are the least reliable, predictable sciences of all. They are narratives dressed up as proven scientific theories, possess the appearance of Science. Pseudoscience.
This Marxist website I found to be very informative and useful. Not because I agree with the perspective of the author, but because the author does a good job of citing sources, references that the reader can go back to validate, read even more about the origins of the Science Wars that first broke out in higher ed back in the 1960's-1970's. Culminating in *the* Science War the author and most in academia think about that transpired in the 1990's:
The reason "Science Wars" are just a small, niche debate anymore is because the Soft, Social Sciences won the war. Almost all we know as "Science" today is infused with social science agendas and narratives. Using Hard, Natural Sciences to buttress a desired narrative when called upon, ignored when it debunks a desired narrative. Hard, Natural Sciences are merely a prop today for the Soft, Social scientists. They've even appropriated another scientific term, "engineering" to describe the process of reordering society as "social engineering." Or even "human engineering" to encompass eugenics/genetics research and application.
Masks are a Soft, Social Science device. "Nonpharmaceutical Interventions" that rely on psychology, amygdala, fear amplification, to make people fearful of an invisible threat lingering in the air, emanating from other people. The "science" of fear that terrorists like plane hijackers and bank robbers implicitly knew. "Be scared," "stay away," "do what I say." Epidemiologists are highly trained in Social and Behavioral Science (I shorten to BS), theory of keeping people apart to "slow the spread." Anti-socializing devices. Terrorizing the same to the amygdala as seeing a snake.
So when the Scamdemic "science" voices saying masks are scientifically proven to protect despite all the Hard, Natural Science evidence showing they don't work they they are relying on Soft, Social Science evidence that shows psychologically people were more obedient, stayed away from others when masks were widespread. A significant percentage correlation with obedience. Not with resulting lower rates of dis-ease. Theory being that more people avoiding each other would result in lower rates...that never materialized.
The 'scientific' case for masks was always hiding in the ambiguity of the word, "Science." Had they been asked to distinguish what *type* of Science they were asserting supported masking they would've been revealed to be relying on BS pseudoscience. When CDC Director Robert Redfield held up his mask before Congress and asserted that "masks are most effective protection backed by the best science" he was saying the psychology of them, amygdala 'see a snake' fear was effective, backed by pseudoscience.
All of that background to make the nexus to "AI" of your video. How does "AI" treat the different *types* of science when they are blurred as they are today? "Science" of narrative is fully integrated with Science of nature. Just like Marx and Engels said when they declared "there is only one science." I disagree. I think the Science Wars needs to be relaunched and the Hard, Natural Sciences need to prevail. If "AI" is to do anything that remotely involves public policy, reliance on by us individually and as a larger public must be based on real science, not pseudoscience. "AI" is and always will be corrupted by the same thing that any system that relies on input is corrupted by: GIGO. Garbage In Garbage Out. And as long as Soft, Social Science, pseudoscience is a part of the input the output will be corrupted by garbage.
So you agree with Marx and Engels, there is only one science, no distinction between Hard, Natural science and Soft, Social science from your perspective? And LLM's/Mimics/AI/SI will be able to distinguish narrative science from physical sciences?
Hmm. There's an entire debate about what is Science. Once upon a time it was an actual war. Known as "The Science Wars." With a history that the Marxists have been more keen on understanding than most other demo. Because Marx and Engels broached the subject. This is how they discussed Science:
http://www.autodidactproject.org/quote/marxsci2.html
"We know only a single science, the science of history. One can look at history from two sides and divide it into the history of nature and the history of men. The two sides are, however, inseparable; the history of nature and the history of men are dependent on each other so long as men exist. The history of nature, called natural science, does not concern us here; but we will have to examine the history of men, since almost the whole ideology amounts either to a distorted conception of this history or to a complete abstraction from it. Ideology is itself only one of the aspects of this history."
https://tjayaraman.wordpress.com/2017/08/06/marx-on-science/
This is a distinction in Sciences that has been blurred. Because there are types, two general categories, Hard, Natural Science (Chemistry, Biology, Physics, etc) and Soft, Social Science (History, Sociology, Psychology, etc). When most people hear the term "Science" images of machines, microscopes, gyroscopes, chemical assays, etc come to mind. Which is useful for those employing Soft, Social Science to be associated with.
There's a reason the Soft, Social Sciences are also known as "Psuedoscience": Because they take on the appearance and many of the methodologies of Hard, Natural Science. But omit the critical validation steps of RCT, replicable, isolation for causality. For Soft, Social Science, observed correlation is sufficient, replication as a non-exact predictor. Hard, Natural Science demands exact predictability. 100% same result. Soft, Social Science accepts 70-80-90% same result. Results will vary, but a statistically significant percentage of them will be the same.
Social Sciences are the least reliable, predictable sciences of all. They are narratives dressed up as proven scientific theories, possess the appearance of Science. Pseudoscience.
This Marxist website I found to be very informative and useful. Not because I agree with the perspective of the author, but because the author does a good job of citing sources, references that the reader can go back to validate, read even more about the origins of the Science Wars that first broke out in higher ed back in the 1960's-1970's. Culminating in *the* Science War the author and most in academia think about that transpired in the 1990's:
https://magazine.scienceforthepeople.org/vol22-1/science-wars-the-next-generation/
The reason "Science Wars" are just a small, niche debate anymore is because the Soft, Social Sciences won the war. Almost all we know as "Science" today is infused with social science agendas and narratives. Using Hard, Natural Sciences to buttress a desired narrative when called upon, ignored when it debunks a desired narrative. Hard, Natural Sciences are merely a prop today for the Soft, Social scientists. They've even appropriated another scientific term, "engineering" to describe the process of reordering society as "social engineering." Or even "human engineering" to encompass eugenics/genetics research and application.
Masks are a Soft, Social Science device. "Nonpharmaceutical Interventions" that rely on psychology, amygdala, fear amplification, to make people fearful of an invisible threat lingering in the air, emanating from other people. The "science" of fear that terrorists like plane hijackers and bank robbers implicitly knew. "Be scared," "stay away," "do what I say." Epidemiologists are highly trained in Social and Behavioral Science (I shorten to BS), theory of keeping people apart to "slow the spread." Anti-socializing devices. Terrorizing the same to the amygdala as seeing a snake.
So when the Scamdemic "science" voices saying masks are scientifically proven to protect despite all the Hard, Natural Science evidence showing they don't work they they are relying on Soft, Social Science evidence that shows psychologically people were more obedient, stayed away from others when masks were widespread. A significant percentage correlation with obedience. Not with resulting lower rates of dis-ease. Theory being that more people avoiding each other would result in lower rates...that never materialized.
The 'scientific' case for masks was always hiding in the ambiguity of the word, "Science." Had they been asked to distinguish what *type* of Science they were asserting supported masking they would've been revealed to be relying on BS pseudoscience. When CDC Director Robert Redfield held up his mask before Congress and asserted that "masks are most effective protection backed by the best science" he was saying the psychology of them, amygdala 'see a snake' fear was effective, backed by pseudoscience.
All of that background to make the nexus to "AI" of your video. How does "AI" treat the different *types* of science when they are blurred as they are today? "Science" of narrative is fully integrated with Science of nature. Just like Marx and Engels said when they declared "there is only one science." I disagree. I think the Science Wars needs to be relaunched and the Hard, Natural Sciences need to prevail. If "AI" is to do anything that remotely involves public policy, reliance on by us individually and as a larger public must be based on real science, not pseudoscience. "AI" is and always will be corrupted by the same thing that any system that relies on input is corrupted by: GIGO. Garbage In Garbage Out. And as long as Soft, Social Science, pseudoscience is a part of the input the output will be corrupted by garbage.
I don’t see any hard line. All… Bayesian. 🤷 Of course, it’s rare to find the same sorts of precision and GUTs possible in soft as hard.
So you agree with Marx and Engels, there is only one science, no distinction between Hard, Natural science and Soft, Social science from your perspective? And LLM's/Mimics/AI/SI will be able to distinguish narrative science from physical sciences?
I think there’s a distinction, but both can still be handled by Bayes. And AI knows the difference too.
I withhold judgement. Jury is still out on that following my reasoning values.